Email Copywriting Guide
Short subject lines get higher open rates. Here's how to write them.
You spend an hour writing the perfect email. Beautiful product images. Compelling offer. Great copy. Then you spend 30 seconds on the subject line. And nobody opens it.
Subject lines are the gatekeepers. It doesn't matter how good your email content is if the subject line doesn't get the open. And most eCommerce brands are still writing subject lines the way they did in 2019, all caps, emoji spam, and vague promises like "Don't Miss Out!!!" Gmail literally uses patterns like that to filter emails into Promotions or spam.
GOSH has worked with 150+ eCommerce clients and A/B tests subject lines. The patterns are clear, and they're probably the opposite of what you'd expect. Shorter beats longer. Specific beats vague. Boring beats clever. Here's the playbook.
150+
Clients
$70M+
Revenue
$23M+
Ad Spend
Klaviyo Gold Partner
Klaviyo Gold Partner
How to fix this, step by step
Keep subject lines short enough for mobile
Klaviyo's own data shows subject lines under 40 characters test higher than longer ones. On mobile, where most emails are opened, long subject lines get truncated. "Your order ships free" beats "Amazing Limited-Time Offer: Free Shipping On All Orders This Weekend Only!" Every character should earn its place. If you can say it in fewer words, do it.
Use sentence case, never Title Case or ALL CAPS
Title Case looks like marketing. Sentence case looks like a message from a person. "New arrivals just dropped" feels like a text from a friend. "New Arrivals Just Dropped For A Limited Time" feels like a billboard. And ALL CAPS triggers spam filters, "HUGE SALE TODAY" is basically asking Gmail to flag you. Sentence case usually tests higher than other formats. It's subtle, but at scale those percentage points compound.
Front-load the benefit or curiosity element
Most people see the first 4-6 words of a subject line before deciding to open or scroll past. Put the most important word first. "Free shipping on your next order" is better than "Psst, we have a special surprise: free shipping." "Your results are ready" beats "We wanted to share something exciting with you today." The benefit or curiosity hook needs to hit in the first few words or it doesn't hit at all.
Drop the emojis (yes, really)
Emojis in subject lines were a competitive advantage in 2018. Now they're so overused that they're actually a spam signal for many inbox filters. Our A/B test data from client accounts shows emoji subject lines perform the same or worse than plain text in 2025-2026. The exception: if your brand voice is genuinely playful and your audience skews Gen Z, a single relevant emoji can work. But "๐ฅ๐ฅ๐ฅ HUGE SALE ๐ฅ๐ฅ๐ฅ" is always a loss.
Use preview text as a complement, not a repeat
Preview text (the gray text after the subject line in the inbox) is your second chance to hook someone. Don't waste it by repeating the subject line. If the subject is "Your cart is waiting," the preview text should add new info: "Plus: free shipping if you complete today." In Klaviyo, you can set preview text for every email. Use it on every single send. Brands that optimize preview text see higher open rates versus those that leave it blank.
A/B test every campaign subject line
Stop guessing. Klaviyo lets you A/B test subject lines on every campaign, send two versions to a slice of your segment, then automatically send the winner to the rest. Test one variable at a time: length, tone, personalization, or format. Over 3-6 months of consistent testing, you'll have a data-backed playbook of what your specific audience actually opens. Our best-performing clients test every single campaign. No exceptions.
Want us to handle this?
These six principles will immediately improve your open rates. You can implement them starting with your next campaign. And we genuinely recommend you do.
But subject lines are one piece of the email puzzle. Open rates depend on deliverability, segmentation, send timing, sender reputation, and list health. If your open rates are still too low after applying these principles, the problem is deeper than subject lines. We do complete email audits, deliverability, flows, segmentation, and campaigns, for Klaviyo accounts. The first one is free.
Honest answers to
common questions
Want a subject line audit with data-backed recommendations?
We'll review your last 30 campaigns, identify what's working and what's not, and give you a custom subject line playbook based on your brand and audience.
Pick a Time30 minutes. No pitch deck. Just your data and our honest take.
More guides
Email Marketing Guide
Your open rates are dropping. And it's probably not your subject lines.
Email open rates too low? The fix isn't a better subject line, it's your sender reputation. Here's the exact playbook from a Klaviyo Gold Partner.
Learn moreEmail Performance Guide
People are opening your emails but not clicking. Why?
Getting opens but no clicks? Your email layout is the problem. Here's the eCommerce email design playbook that consistently drives clicks.
Learn moreEmail Retention Guide
You don't have an unsubscribe problem. You have a relevance problem.
Unsubscribe rate strong? You're not emailing too much, you're emailing the wrong people. Here's how to fix it without sending less.
Learn moreEmail Segmentation Guide
Segmentation is the change that turns a quiet email channel into one that actually sells.
Sending the same email to everyone? Segmented campaigns drive much more revenue per send. Here's the exact segmentation playbook for Klaviyo.
Learn moreEmail Automation Guide
Email flows generate email revenue. Most stores have them broken or missing.
The 7 email flows every eCommerce store needs, with exact timing, content, and structure. From a Klaviyo Gold Partner and the team behind 150+ eCommerce clients.
Learn moreEmail Deliverability Guide
Stop. Before you send that first campaign, you need to warm up your domain.
New sending domain? Migrating to Klaviyo? Skip the warmup and you'll land in spam. Here's the exact 30-day warmup schedule from a Klaviyo Gold Partner.
Learn moreNeed help with this?
Book a free call