Email Segmentation Guide
Segmentation is the change that turns a quiet email channel into one that actually sells.
Most stores have email that is technically working, just not carrying its share of revenue. Not bad. But they send the same email to the entire list twice a week.
Do not start by changing offers, redesigning templates, or writing new copy. Segment the list and match content to each group. VIP customers get exclusive early access. New subscribers get educational content. Lapsed customers get win-back offers. Once the work is in market, the list has a clearer path to revenue.
Segmentation is not a nice to have. It is the first thing you should do in email marketing. Here is exactly how to do it in Klaviyo.
150+
Clients
$70M+
Revenue
$23M+
Ad Spend
Klaviyo Gold Partner
Klaviyo Gold Partner
How to fix this, step by step
Build engagement-based segments first
These are your foundation. Create four segments in Klaviyo: Engaged 30 Days (opened or clicked in last 30 days), Engaged 60 Days (same but 60 days), Engaged 90 Days (same but 90 days), and Unengaged 120+ Days (no opens or clicks in 120+ days). Every campaign goes to one of these segments, never to "all subscribers." This alone protects your deliverability and increases open rates in a measurable way because you're only emailing people who actually interact with you.
Create purchase behavior segments
Layer in purchase data: First-Time Buyers (exactly 1 order), Repeat Buyers (2+ orders), VIP Customers (highest-revenue or 4+ orders), High AOV (orders above your average), and Never Purchased (on your list but zero orders). Each of these groups responds to completely different messaging. A first-time buyer needs confidence. A VIP needs exclusivity. Someone who's never bought needs a reason to start.
Segment by product category or collection
If you sell across multiple categories, say skincare and makeup, or men's and women's clothing, segment by what people actually buy. In Klaviyo, create segments like "Purchased from Skincare collection at least once" or "Browsed Men's category 3+ times." Then send category-specific content to each group. Someone who only buys skincare doesn't want makeup emails. This reduces unsubscribes and increases click rates because every email feels personally relevant.
Build lifecycle segments that update automatically
Combine engagement and purchase data into lifecycle segments: New Subscriber (joined in last 14 days, hasn't purchased), Active Customer (purchased in last 60 days), At-Risk (purchased before but no activity in 60-90 days), Lapsed (no activity in 90-150 days), and Churned (no activity in a long stretch). These segments update in real time as people move through the lifecycle. Map specific campaigns and flows to each stage, each group needs fundamentally different messaging.
Use predictive segments for advanced targeting
Klaviyo has built-in predictive analytics: Predicted Gender, Predicted Next Order Date, Predicted Churn Risk, and Predicted Customer Lifetime Value. Use these to create segments like "High LTV customers who are at risk of churning", that's your highest-priority save list. Or "Customers whose next predicted order date is once the work is in market", send them a replenishment reminder. Predictive segments let you be proactive instead of reactive.
Map your campaign calendar to your segments
Create a campaign matrix: for each campaign type (promotion, new arrival, educational, seasonal), decide which segments receive it. VIPs get early access 24 hours before everyone else. New subscribers get educational content mixed with soft sells. Lapsed customers get re-engagement offers. Never send the same campaign to every segment. Even if the offer is the same, customize the subject line and opening paragraph for each group. This takes more time per campaign but generates much higher the revenue.
Want us to handle this?
Steps 1 through 4 are things you can build in Klaviyo this week. And honestly, just implementing engagement-based segments will improve your email performance dramatically.
But the optimization layer, predictive segments, dynamic content that changes per segment, lifecycle-triggered campaigns, continuous A/B testing across segments, that's where brands go from good to exceptional. We build and manage these systems for eCommerce brands. If you want us to look at your current segmentation and show you where the gaps are, book a call. We'll map out a custom strategy.
Honest answers to
common questions
Want a custom segmentation strategy for your store?
We'll analyze your Klaviyo data, build a recommended segment architecture, and show you exactly which content each segment should receive. Free strategy call.
Pick a Time30 minutes. No pitch deck. Just your data and our honest take.
More guides
Email Automation Guide
Email flows generate email revenue. Most stores have them broken or missing.
The 7 email flows every eCommerce store needs, with exact timing, content, and structure. From a Klaviyo Gold Partner and the team behind 150+ eCommerce clients.
Learn moreEmail Marketing Guide
Your open rates are dropping. And it's probably not your subject lines.
Email open rates too low? The fix isn't a better subject line, it's your sender reputation. Here's the exact playbook from a Klaviyo Gold Partner.
Learn moreEmail Retention Guide
You don't have an unsubscribe problem. You have a relevance problem.
Unsubscribe rate strong? You're not emailing too much, you're emailing the wrong people. Here's how to fix it without sending less.
Learn moreList Building Guide
The average eCommerce store converts too few visitors into email subscribers. Here's how to do better.
Growing your eCommerce email list from zero? Here is the playbook: popups, lead magnets, and signup strategies that convert visitors.
Learn moreEmail Performance Guide
People are opening your emails but not clicking. Why?
Getting opens but no clicks? Your email layout is the problem. Here's the eCommerce email design playbook that consistently drives clicks.
Learn moreKlaviyo Setup Guide
Stores using Klaviyo properly drive revenue from email. Here's how to set it up right.
Step-by-step guide to setting up Klaviyo on your Shopify store, from installation to your first automated flow. Written by a Klaviyo Gold Partner.
Learn moreNeed help with this?
Book a free call