eCommerce Platform Comparison
Magento is incredibly powerful. It's also incredibly expensive and incredibly slow to build on.
Magento, now Adobe Commerce, is the enterprise eCommerce platform. Unlimited customization, total control, and the ability to build literally anything. The trade-off: it requires dedicated developers, costs a lot more to build, and takes much longer to launch. For the right brand at the right scale, Magento is the correct choice. For most eCommerce brands, it's massive overkill. Shopify gives you most of the functionality at a fraction of the cost and timeline.
150+
Clients
$70M+
Revenue
$23M+
Ad Spend
Klaviyo Gold Partner
Partner
Magento is the right tool for enterprise brands with complex requirements: multi-store, multi-currency, complex B2B catalogs, and highly custom checkout flows. But for most DTC brands, Shopify or Shopify Plus is faster, cheaper, and easier to maintain.
Shopify vs Magento (Adobe Commerce): feature by feature
| Feature | Shopify | Magento (Adobe Commerce) |
|---|---|---|
| Total Cost of Ownership | Predictable monthly platform cost plus apps. You know the bill before it arrives. | High initial build cost. Ongoing hosting, maintenance, and developer support. Ongoing developer dependency. |
| Time to Launch | Weeks for most stores. Custom builds take longer, still much faster than Magento. | Months for a proper build. Complex enterprise implementations can take a year or more. |
| Customization | Highly customizable within Shopify's framework. Shopify Plus removes most limitations. Headless builds for full control. | Unlimited customization. Full code access, no platform limitations. Build literally anything. |
| Hosting & Maintenance | Fully managed by Shopify. Zero hosting, security, or maintenance burden. | Self-hosted (open source) or Adobe-managed (Commerce Cloud). Either way, you need DevOps expertise. |
| Scalability | Handles any traffic volume natively. Shopify Plus for enterprise. Black Friday? No sweat. | Scales with infrastructure investment. Can handle massive volume but requires careful server management. |
| Developer Requirements | Minimal. Most customization via theme editor and apps. Developers needed for custom features. | Requires dedicated PHP/Magento developers. The platform is complex and finding qualified developers is expensive. |
Our recommendation
Shopify for most eCommerce brands. Shopify Plus for brands that need enterprise features. Magento only for true enterprise brands with complex requirements that Shopify Plus genuinely can't handle, and even then, evaluate carefully.
Pick Shopify if...
Pick Shopify if you want to launch fast, scale without infrastructure headaches, and spend your budget on marketing instead of development.
Pick Magento (Adobe Commerce) if...
Pick Magento if you're an enterprise brand with highly complex product catalogs, multi-store requirements, or custom B2B workflows that Shopify Plus genuinely can't accommodate.
Honest answers to
common questions
Thinking about migrating from Magento to Shopify?
We'll assess your current Magento setup, plan the migration, and make sure you don't lose rankings or customers in the process.
Pick a Time30 minutes. No pitch deck. Just your data and our honest take.
More comparisons
eCommerce Platform Comparison
Shopify or BigCommerce: which one should you actually build on?
Shopify vs BigCommerce: we've built on both. An honest comparison for eCommerce brands choosing their platform.
Learn moreeCommerce Platform Comparison
Squarespace makes beautiful websites. Shopify makes money.
Shopify vs Squarespace: one is built for selling, the other for looking good. Which one your online store needs.
Learn morePlatform Migration Guide
GOSH has worked with 150+ eCommerce clients. We work on Shopify migrations. The checklist below protects your rankings.
Migrating to Shopify from WooCommerce, Magento, or BigCommerce? Here's the complete checklist so you don't lose your rankings, data, or sanity.
Learn moreShopify Plus Guide
Is Shopify Plus worth the monthly fee? That depends on what you do with it.
Thinking about Shopify Plus? Here's what you actually get, who it's for, and how to set it up right, from an agency that builds on Plus every day.
Learn moreShopify Growth Guide
Most Shopify stores leave conversions on the table. Here's how to beat that.
Shopify sales stuck? Here are the 6 highest-impact changes to drive more revenue, from traffic to conversion to retention. Real data from 150+ clients.
Learn moreSales Channel Comparison
Amazon gives you customers. Shopify gives you a brand. Which do you need more?
Shopify gives you brand control. Amazon gives you traffic. How to decide, or use both strategically.
Learn moreNot sure which to pick?
Book a free call