Email Copywriting Guide

Your open rates are fine. So why is nobody clicking?

You've fixed your deliverability. Your open rates are solid. But your click-through rate is stuck where they should not be. People are opening your emails and then doing nothing. They read (maybe skim), close, and move on with their day.

The problem isn't your subject line, that got them to open. The problem is what happens after they open. Your email body doesn't give them a reason to click. It's either a wall of text nobody wants to read, a discount-only message they've seen 50 times, or a generic product grid with no context for why they should care about those specific products right now.

Writing an email that gets clicked is a different skill than writing one that gets opened. It requires a clear value proposition within the first two sentences, a single focused CTA, and copy that speaks to where the reader is in their customer path. Here's the framework.

150+

Clients

$70M+

Revenue

$23M+

Ad Spend

Klaviyo Gold Partner

Klaviyo Gold Partner

How to fix this, step by step

1

Lead with the value in the first two lines

The preview text and first two lines of your email determine whether someone keeps reading or closes it. Don't waste them on "Hi [Name], we're excited to share." Get to the point: "Your most-requested color is finally back, and it's selling fast." The value, what's in it for them, needs to be immediate and specific. If someone can't understand why this email matters within 3 seconds, you've lost them.

2

Write for one person, not your entire list

Stop writing like a brand talking to an audience. Write like one person emailing a friend. Use "you" and "your," not "our customers" or "subscribers." Tell them what they specifically should do: "You left this in your cart" is better than "Don't forget about the items in your cart." Personal, direct, specific. Every email should feel like it was written for the person reading it.

3

One email, one goal, one CTA

The #1 email copywriting mistake: too many links and too many asks. An email with 8 product links and 3 different CTAs converts worse than an email with one focused product and one "Shop Now" button. Pick one goal per email. Is it driving traffic to a new collection? Then everything in the email supports that single goal. No sidebar links. No footer promotions. One path, one destination.

4

Use urgency that's real, not manufactured

Manufactured urgency: "SALE ENDS TONIGHT!!!" (it doesn't). Real urgency: "We made 200 units. 47 are left." Real urgency works because it's believable. Stock-based urgency (limited quantities), time-based urgency (actual deadlines), and access-based urgency (email-exclusive, first access before public launch) all drive clicks when they're true. Fake urgency trains people to ignore your emails.

5

Make the CTA button impossible to miss

Your CTA button should be above the fold on mobile, use a contrasting color, and have specific action text. "Shop Now" is fine but "Get Your Size Before It Sells Out" is better. Make the button at least 44px tall for mobile tappability. Include it once above the fold and once at the bottom. If someone has to scroll past three paragraphs to find your button, most of them won't.

6

Test one variable at a time and let data decide

A/B test in Klaviyo: subject lines first (biggest impact on opens), then CTA copy and placement (biggest impact on clicks), then email length and layout. Change one thing per test. Run each test to at least 1,000 recipients per variation for statistical validity. Keep what wins, test the next variable. Compounding small improvements across tests is how you go from a low base click rate to a healthier range.

Want us to handle this?

These six principles will change your email click rates. Go audit your last five campaigns against this checklist, you'll immediately see what's been holding you back.

But writing great emails consistently is a skill that compounds with data. Knowing which products to feature, when to send, how to segment your messaging, and how to A/B test at scale, that's what we do for our Klaviyo clients every day. If you want us to review your email copy and campaigns, that first audit is free.

Get an Email Copy AuditWe'll walk through your setup live.
FAQ

Honest answers to
common questions

Want a professional audit of your email campaigns?

We'll review your recent campaigns, identify what's hurting your click rates, and deliver specific rewrite recommendations. Free email copy audit.

Pick a Time

30 minutes. No pitch deck. Just your data and our honest take.

Need help with this?

Book a free call

Book Call