Channel Comparison

Email drives volume. SMS drives urgency. The best brands use both. Here is how.

Email and SMS aren't competing channels: they're complementary. Email is your workhorse: long-form content, product showcases, brand storytelling, and automated flows that run around the clock. SMS is your closer: flash sale alerts, cart recovery nudges, shipping notifications, and time-sensitive offers that demand immediate attention. Running both on Klaviyo means one platform, one customer profile, and coordinated messaging that doesn't overwhelm.

150+

Clients

$70M+

Revenue

$23M+

Ad Spend

Klaviyo Gold Partner

Partner

Email marketing is the foundation: it should carry a meaningful slice of total revenue through flows and campaigns. SMS is the accelerator: it adds on top of your email revenue by reaching customers in the most immediate channel possible. Klaviyo lets you run both from one platform, which is the right approach.

Email Marketing vs SMS Marketing: feature by feature

FeatureEmail MarketingSMS Marketing
Open RatesSolid for well-managed eCommerce lists. Varies by deliverability and segmentation.Nearly every text is read. The open rate advantage is massive.
Content FormatRich content: images, HTML, long copy, product grids, dynamic blocks. Tell a full story.Short text plus optional image or link. Get to the point in a sentence or two.
Frequency ToleranceA few campaigns per week for engaged segments. Higher tolerance for content variety.A few texts per month maximum. Over-texting causes fast opt-outs. Reserve for high-impact moments.
CostMonthly platform fee on Klaviyo. Essentially free per send after that.Per-message cost that adds up at scale. More expensive per message than email.
Revenue ContributionThe primary owned-channel revenue driver for optimized programs.Additive to email. Best for flash sales, time-sensitive offers, and cart recovery.
ComplianceStandard email consent under CAN-SPAM and GDPR. Relatively straightforward.Strict TCPA compliance. Explicit opt-in required. Fines per unsolicited text are steep. Higher legal bar.

Our recommendation

Don't choose between them. Build email first, it drives more total revenue, then layer SMS on top for high-impact moments. On Klaviyo, they share the same customer profiles and can be coordinated in the same flows. Email should carry the volume. SMS should add urgency on top.

Pick Email Marketing if...

If you can only afford one channel, email comes first. It drives more total revenue, supports more content types, and costs less per message. Build flows, grow your list, optimize campaigns.

Pick SMS Marketing if...

Add SMS once your email program is established, flows running and email already contributing real revenue. SMS accelerates results, especially for flash sales, BFCM, and cart recovery for high-value carts.

FAQ

Honest answers to
common questions

Want to see how much revenue email + SMS should be driving?

We'll audit your current email and SMS setup, show you the revenue gap, and build a plan to close it. Free audit.

Pick a Time

30 minutes. No pitch deck. Just your data and our honest take.

Not sure which to pick?

Book a free call

Book Call